Thursday, November 6, 2014

Mapping pre-1600 European manuscripts in the U.S. and Canada

Pre-1600 European manuscripts in the United States and Canada (detail)

Today marks the beginning of the 7th annual Schoenberg Symposium on Manuscript Studies in the Digital Age here in Philadelphia. This year the symposium theme is "Collecting Histories" and features a line up of speakers discussing the ways in which provenance and the history of collecting informs our wider knowledge about manuscript culture. As readers of this blog know, I'm very much interested in the historical movement of books and manuscripts and I'm excited to speak during the conference on the ways in which the Schoenberg Database of Manuscripts (SDBM) can be used to track manuscripts over time.

For this post though I want to highlight the fantastic work done by a team of scholars whose work very much informs the SDBM project. Over the past two decades, Lisa Fagin Davis and Melissa Conway have worked to create a new directory for all institutions in the U.S. and Canada which hold European manuscripts dating to before 1600. They have published their own excellent description of the origins and methodology of the project but in short their work began as a way to update the censuses of American manuscripts created by Seymour de Ricci from 1935-40 and supplemented by Faye and Bond in 1962. Their census includes entries for 937 entities:  historical owners of manuscripts derived from previous censuses, the former names of institutions now renamed, as well as current holders. Running to 126 pages in a freely available PDF sponsored by the Bibliographical Society of America, the census is an incredibly helpful resource and I wanted to find a way to make the data contained within it browseable in a different way than just on the printed page.

Example of a listing from the Fagin Davis & Conway Census (p.37)
I extracted the text from the PDF census and chopped it up into relevant delimited fields like "Name" "Address" "Holdings" etc.  and then mapped the results using CartoDB. I had to make a few decisions about display along the way, especially when it came to how to determine the size of each manuscript owning dot on the map. Most institutions provided Fagin Davis and Conway with numbers for how many manuscript codices they held as well as how many leaves, documents, and scrolls were in their collection (though others reported only an aggregate number). Most institutions with full-fledged manuscript books had a fairly well-informed count of exactly how many they had but the numbers for leaves and documents often were estimated in larger round figures. As a result, the default map view gives all locations in the census with dots on their locations by number of total manuscripts held (leaves, codices, scrolls, documents, etc.). Using the "visible layers" dropdown you can turn off and on just those locations currently holding manuscripts or just those recorded in earlier censuses which no longer hold manuscripts or both together. Of course sizing the dots by total manuscript holdings will be necessarily a bit misleading as a university with 2 codices and 37 leaves appears to have total holdings of 39 manuscripts, so there is also an option in the "visible layers" menu to view only holdings of codices.



Unsurprisingly one can see the concentration of pre-1600 European manuscript holdings along the east coast. In a league table of manuscript holders New York, Washington, and Philadelphia(!) come out on top by volume but in terms of individual institutions the Huntington and Folger with their extensive holdings of pre-1600 documents come out on top.

Top-15 current owners of pre-1600 manuscripts by "total" count in the Fagin-Davis/Conway census
Given the fuzziness of this catch-all "total" manuscript number it's helpful to also get a sense of institutions by number of codices held:

Top 15 current owners of pre-1600 manuscript codices in the Fagin Davis/Conway census
One of the advantages of using the Fagin Davis and Conway survey is that it lists private collections, and in the cases where these were dispersed or relocated, notes their current location. I don't think it would be terribly controversial to say that most collections of medieval manuscripts in the U.S. and Canada rest on substantial gifts from individual collectors or families. The remarkable extent of these private collections can be seen in part below:

Collections of pre-1600 manuscripts now identified as being relocated in the Fagin Davis/Conway census
Top 15 now-relocated collections of pre-1600 manuscript codices in the census

It's edifying to see the late Larry Schoernberg at the top of the list of codices, especially today during the conference celebrating his legacy. His manuscripts are now here at Penn but a decade ago when they were in Longboat Key, Florida they made that small community the largest holder of pre-1600 manuscript codices in the south. Others on that list will be familiar to many, including George Plimpton whose manuscripts are now largely at Columbia University and Thomas Marston whose collection is at the Beinecke, and Ricketts, whose collection is now mostly at the Lilly library.



Fagin Davis and Conway have already written on the implications of their survey for the history of manuscript movement but I was curious to see how manuscript holdings related to holdings of early printed books.  Since I had data on incunabula holdings for the U.S. and Canada handy I thought I would overlay the two sets of information together.


 Holdings of pre-1600 manuscripts (orange) and pre-1500 printed books (green)

As one would expect, the majority of institutions with pre-1600 manuscripts also hold pre-1500 printed books with the major institutions of the east and west coasts remaining prominent. Though it is de rigueur now to speak of early printed books and manuscripts as complementary genres rather than necessarily competing ones, I know from experience in special collections libraries that print and manuscript remain separate in many places and that historically collectors of one genre might not necessarily be interested in the other (Larry Schoenberg for instance was a manuscript collector and for the most part did not own incunabula). I was surprised then to see how well the two sets of data overlap - that is, there were many fewer outliers than I expected. There were a few though such as the Mount Angel Abbey Library in Benedict Oregon which reported 25 codices and 63 pre-1600 leaves but is not listed in the GW as possessing any incunabula (though they may very well have them!). Or a smattering of public collections which have small collections of either incunabula or manuscripts but not both. The Lima Public Library in Lima, Ohio for instance reports holdings of 68 pre-1600 manuscript leaves but no early printed books. Though I'm still working on wrangling the data between the two sets, I'm eager to see what other small collections or big discrepancies pop up.

Finally, if you're interested in learning more about medieval manuscript collections in the U.S. ckeck out the program of this weekend's conference as well as Lisa Fagin Davis' blog detailing her virtual travels to manuscript repositories around the country over the past year.

52 comments:

  1. Remarkably similar to www.digitizedmedievalmanuscripts.org and its DMMmaps, excluding the rest of the world?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Giulio. What I think makes this different is that the map of digitized medieval manuscripts includes only those that have been digitized which excludes about 90% of U.S. and Canadian collections who haven't yet digitized a single manuscript. I wanted a way for folks to see where manuscripts where located whether digitized or not. Though it would be very cool to overlay the two and see where the big digitizers are!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mitch, I'm not sure I ever saw this post! These maps are fantastic. So cool to see our data being mined this way!

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. When it becomes difficult to sort out certain issues you almost used to look forward to many other principles going to take part in great help and almost doing well. dissertation typing service

    ReplyDelete
  6. http://www.canic.ws/business and personal webpages from canada.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm interested in learning more about medieval manuscript collections in the U.S. and I will check this out a bit later. By visiting ​http://dissertationwriting.services/, you will be much more aware of the dissertation writing process.

    ReplyDelete
  8. http://www.canic.ws/ business and personal webpages from canada.

    ReplyDelete
  9. http://www.canic.ws business and personal webpages from canada.

    ReplyDelete
  10. http://www.canic.ws business and personal webpages from canada.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks for sharing this with us! Some really amazing features.

    Flat Earth Map

    ReplyDelete
  12. This Manuscripts about US and Canada. Thanks for discuss about Manuscripts and other information. You can try this manuscript typing services provide for the people and help them. I am waiting for your reply.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Well very well done.Good job.Thank you.My little brother made this site http://www.typingrates.com/secrets-about-typing-job-for-students/.check it guys.Hope you will like it.

    ReplyDelete
  14. The particular outsource legitimate companies are usually which can be supporting in numerous techniques. Thus just click here and acquire more details http://www.cheapproofreading.net/our-cheap-proofreading-services/best-cheap-editing-service/.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Map is the source which help us to know the whole distances from one area to another. The vastness of area and detail of oceans might be judge through such map. This help also available in good service for others.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Get Instant Printing provides Catalogues Books Printing at a very cheap price in the UK market. We offer high-quality wholesale catalog printing and booklet printing.
    Catalogues Books Printing

    ReplyDelete
  17. Before forming an article an understudy must think about its gathering of spectators. He should make sense of Will's character scrutinizing his article. By http://www.originalitychecker.net/essay-similarity-checker-being-original/ site should revolve around the topic as demonstrated by the essential of the peruses.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Good post, A teacher should get inclusion and figure out how to trade it to other age. He should take manage from their seniors, authorities and this look here site other handy educators who have been serving in this calling for a long time.

    ReplyDelete
  19. This is one of the best and valuable blog, I have seen since past some time. Thank you so much for sharing this blog with. Visit Ogen Infosystem for Creative Website Designing Services.
    Website Designing Company in Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  20. Awesome and Valuable information in this blog. Visit Y&H Cargo India for best Logistics and Shipping Company Services.
    Freight Forwarders in Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  21. Nice blog, get the best Truck Branding Services in India by Kala Kutir Pvt Ltd.
    Truck Branding Services in india

    ReplyDelete
  22. Visit Djcareerindia for Top 5 DJ Schools and DJ Course in Jalandhar and Top 5 DJ Schools and DJ Course in Visakhapatnam.
    Top 5 DJ Schools and DJ Course in Jalandhar (2019 Rankings)

    ReplyDelete
  23. I feel happy about and learning more about this topic. keep sharing your information regularly for my future reference. This content creates new hope and inspiration within me. Thanks for sharing an article like this. the information which you have provided is better than another blog.
    IELTS Coaching in Delhi

    overseas Education Consultants

    ReplyDelete
  24. Usually I never comment on blogs but your article is so convincing that I never stop myself to say something about it. You’re doing a great job Man,Keep it up.
    study in uk consultants in delhi
    ielts coaching in gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  25. Printing services in Delhi Full services with guaranteed quality & on time delivery.We provide all printing service like catalogue Printingcatalogue printing in gurgaomaqsw , Letterhead Printing Catalog Printing Services, Catalog Printing Providers in India.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Our Catalogcatalogue printing in Delhi Designing in Delhi provides creative Online Product Catalog design Printing with guaranteed quality and on-time delivery at low prices with expert support.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Our Catalog DesigningWe provide all printing service like catalogue Printing in Delhi provides creative Online Product Catalog design Printing with guaranteed quality and on-time delivery at low prices with expert support.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Abhiprint brings in Booklet printing in Delhi of best with extraordinary quality. we are offering highly reliable services of printing on various types of papers. Booklet is printed using state-of-the-art printers, and high-grade ink. We use the latest printing technology to make our printed products outstanding in the market. We offer printing services like booklet printing services, annual report printing services, calendar printing services, book printing services.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Abhiprint offer different type of creative Booklets booklet printing in delhi Brochure catalog printing offset Digital Printing services in Delhi, A full services with guaranteed quality and on-time delivery full color on front or both sides, or black or blank on the back Folding options only 1 cent each for any size! FREE gloss aqueous coating Optional UV coating for extra shine and durability 4-day production (rush available) Full-service direct mailing.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Catalogues We provide all printing service like catalogue Printing look good and attract the viewer easily. Usually the pictures are presented in such a manner that it grabs all the attention and people forget to read the text. Catalogues feature large images that capture the viewer's eye and hold it for a longer interval. They solve the purpose in a better way as they are more compact and can easily be taken to a prospective client or distributed among the interested buyers. They can also be kept at the sales counter to be shown to the buyers, that is how they get to select a product suiting their taste from a range of other products.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Usually I never comment on blogs but your article is so convincing that I never stop myself to say something about it. You’re doing a great job Man,Keep it up.
    overseas education consultants
    ielts coaching in gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  32. Related Services. 3D Printing. Balloon Printing. printing services in Delhi Book Printing. Brochure Printing. Bulk Calendar Printing. Caps Screen Printing. Cloth Banner Printing. Cd & Dvd Printing. Danglers Printing. Diary Printing. Digital & Flex Printing The Abhi Print offers the most comprehensive clothes banner printing solutions in offset printing of Catalogue Printing, Brochure Printing, Booklet Printing, Business Cards Printing, Letterheads Printing, Flyers Printing, Envelopes Printing, Poster Printing services at the lowest price.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Our Catalog Catalogue Printing in Delhi Designing in Delhi provides creative Online Product Catalog design Printing with guaranteed quality and on-time delivery at low prices with expert support.
    Catalog Printing with guaranteed quality and on-time delivery at low prices with ... Many Custom Options Available ... Custom Catalog and Booklet Printing.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Usually I never comment on blogs but your article is so convincing that I never stop myself to say something about it. You’re doing a great job Man,Keep it up.
    overseas education consultantsin delhi
    ielts coaching in gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  35. The Abhi Print offers the most comprehensive Best poster printing in Delhi poster printing solutions in offset printing of: poster, poster printing posters online, poster maker, art posters, poster creator, wall posters printing services at the lowest price, photo poster, poster frames, photo poster maker, poster design app, poster pictures, poster app, poster photo editor, poster editor.

    ReplyDelete
  36. At AbhiPrint best catalogue printing company in Delhi. we assure you to provide some great paintings to create a uniquely compact catalog. The elegant product is just a small with a bare minimum copy of the text. With our minimalist design, your list will look attractive, informative and vague which will help attract the attention of potential customers. Image size. And background color as well as counts to achieve the desired result. Our Catalog Designing in Delhi provides creative Online Product Catalog design Printing with guaranteed quality and on-time delivery at low prices with expert support. Catalog Printing at abhiprint - We offer Catalogue Design & printing services. Our catalog designer in Delhi provides creative Product catalog design.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Heavy discounts on Best Brochure Printing Brochure printing company in Delhi Services offered. Fast production for Full -Color Brochure printing in Delhi, Gurgaon, and India. Brochure Printing in Delhi - Get The best price Brochure Printing services with full- Colar Brochure printing. Most effective and cheapest cost in all Over India. High- Quality Brochure Printing Services in Delhi NCR. We Offer a Wide Range of Printing and Designing Services. Best Price Guaranteed. inquiry Now. Excellent Service.

    ReplyDelete

  38. The Abhi Print offers the most comprehensive Letter Head printing Letterhead printing in Delhi solutions in offset printing of Letter Head |letterhead paper |INDIA Best Letter Head service in Delhi business cards letterhead printing letterhead maker letterhead printing online letterhead printing cost services at lowest price.Letterhead is an important part of the corporate image and is often inserted into envelopes for direct mail marketing. This vital promotional tool is often used for business transactions outside the company. However, they can also be used as inserts in product manuals, even as welcome letters and memos. Today, many business professionals use letterheads to gain business advantage by using very high quality offset color printing to showcase the best colors for their business. . If you also want to provide the ideal promotion for your business, then Abhiprint will help you from all angles here.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Abhiprint offer different type of Creative Brochure / catalogue designing and printing services in delhi . A full services with guaranteed quality & on time delivery Wholesale Catalog Printing Wholesale Catalog Printer , Catalogue Printer in Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  40. At AbhiPrint we assure you to provide some great paintings to create a uniquely compact catalog. We provide all printing service like catalogue Printing.The elegant product is just a small with a bare minimum copy of the text. With our minimalist design, your list will look attractive, informative and vague which will help attract the attention of potential customers. Image size. And background color as well as counts to achieve the desired result.Catalogs are a great resource to take any business to success. However, it is necessary that your catalog contains valuable information about the products and services you are offering. We know the importance of your catalog and therefore make sure to include complete information about your products including product pictures, charts, or pictures to complete your sales marketing materials.

    ReplyDelete
  41. At AbhiPrint we assure you to provide some great paintings to create a uniquely compact catalog. The elegant product is just a small with a bare minimum copy of the text. With our minimalist design, your list will look attractive, informative and vague which will help attract the attention of potential customers. catalog design and printing size. Best Catalog Printing Services In Delhi NCR, Catalog Printing In Rohini, Catalog Printing In Gurgaon Best Catalog Printing Services In All Over IndiaOur Catalog Designing in Delhi provides creative Online Product Catalog design Printing with guaranteed quality and on-time delivery at low prices with expert support.And background color as well as counts to achieve the desired result.

    ReplyDelete

  42. Power on your printer. …
    Open the file that contains the poster image. …
    Click the "Preferences" or "Printer Properties" button to open the Printing Preferences dialog box.
    Click the preferred "Page Layout" selection, such as "4 Poster [2x2]," "9 Poster [3x3]" or "16 Poster [4x4]" to select the poster size.Abhi Print offers the most comprehensive poster printingposter printing, posters online poster maker, art posters, poster creator, wall posters, poster making app, photo poster, poster frames, photo poster maker Abhi Print offers the most comprehensive poster printing solutions in offset printing of poster, poster printing posters online, poster maker, art posters, poster creator, wall posters printing services at the lowest price, photo poster, poster frames, photo poster maker, poster design app, poster pictures, poster app, poster photo editor, poster editor.

    ReplyDelete

  43. Power on your printer. …
    Open the file that contains the poster image. …
    Click the "Preferences" or "Printer Properties" button to open the Printing Preferences dialog box.
    Click the preferred "Page Layout" selection, such as "4 Poster [2x2]," "9 Poster [3x3]" or "16 Poster [4x4]" to select the poster size.Best poster printing in Delhi poster printing, posters online poster maker, art posters, poster creator, wall posters, poster making app, photo poster, poster frames, photo poster maker Abhi Print offers the most comprehensive poster printing solutions in offset printing of poster, poster printing posters online, poster maker, art posters, poster creator, wall posters printing services at the lowest price, photo poster, poster frames, photo poster maker, poster design app, poster pictures, poster app, poster photo editor, poster editor.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Abhiprint offer different type of Creative

    Envelope / Professionally Designed Envelope and Printing services in delhi
    . A full services

    with guaranteed quality & on time delivery

    ReplyDelete
  45. At AbhiPrint we assure you to provide some great paintings to create a uniquely compact catalog. We provide all printing service like catalogue Printing We provide all printing service like catalogue PrintingThe elegant product is just a small with a bare minimum copy of the text. With our minimalist design, your list will look attractive, informative and vague which will help attract the attention of potential customers. size. Best Catalog Printing Services In Delhi NCR, Catalog Printing In Rohini, Catalog Printing In Gurgaon Best Catalog Printing Services In All Over IndiaOur Catalog Designing in Delhi provides creative Online Product Catalog design Printing with guaranteed quality and on-time delivery at low prices with expert support.And background color as well as counts to achieve the desired result.Our Catalog Designing in Delhi provides creative Online Product Catalog design Printing with guaranteed quality and on-time delivery at low prices with expert support.

    ReplyDelete
  46. A catalog can be any compilation of items organized in a systematic manner. That's why the list of books available at

    your library might be organized in a digital catalog.
    It can also be used as a verb meaning

    to make a catalog of items or to add an item to a catalog. You can catalog anything!

    ReplyDelete
  47. Nice post!
    Explore Visualr, data visualization and analytics platform , helps business organized their data in simple & connect with MS Excel, My SQL, MS SQL, Oracle or even Flat File databases in an instant.

    ReplyDelete