Thursday, October 10, 2013

Library Markings from Looted Books


Bookplate of the Komite zur Förderung Thoradienst Gemeinden in Palästina Frankfurt a.M.
Here at Penn, the rare books cataloging team has been working for the past several years to put images of bookplates, bookstamps, and other provenance markings online in order to facilitate identification of former owners and libraries.  Thanks to the project, I've become increasingly interested in how digital tools might help scholars reconstruct historical libraries and networks of texts.

I've long been interested in the mass movement of books that took place over the 19th and 20th centuries, whether as a result of the dissolution of monasteries, the increased economic and cultural resources of the United States, or the unprecedented tragedies of the World Wars. The wide-scale looting and destruction of books and cultural artifacts by the Third Reich in the 1930s and 40s has drawn an increasing amount of scholarly interest in the past few decades [1]. Even George Clooney is getting in on the action with his upcoming movie on the "Monuments Men" team that worked to locate and preserve works of art during the last months of the war. In reading more about the fate of books and libraries destroyed or stolen by the Nazi regime I was excited to see that the records kept by the central collecting point for looted books at Offenbach were available both in microfilm and (for a fee) online. These records were largely compiled and saved by Ardelia Hall (1899-1979) who was an adviser to the State Department with a tireless focus on returning looted WWII property.

Front Cover of Vol. II (Western) of the albums assembled at Offenbach
(this image: S.J. Pomrenze Papers, Center for Jewish History)

By mid-1946, U.S. and other allied forced had assembled more than 2 million books from Nazi repositories at Offenbach with the aim of returning books to rightful owners wherever possible. The records of this endeavor are voluminous and are available in some 13 reels of microfilm from the National Archives as NARA M1942. This microfilm series has been digitized by Fold3 and is available to subscribers of that service.

To aid their work of cultural restitution, officers at the Offenbach depot made several albums of photographed bookstamps and marks found inside books in their care, which they organized by apparent place of origin. They also created additional albums featuring markings from private libraries and owners which bore no readily identifiable geographic point of origin. All told the albums contain thousands of ownership marks, a perfect candidate for mapping. Feeling decidedly unqualified to tackle the album of markings from Eastern Europe or the vast number of miscellaneous private stamps,  I started with those from Western Europe. The Western European album compiled at Offenbach includes pages categorized by country, i.e. America, Argentina, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Great Britain, Italy, the Netherlands, Palestine, Spain, and Switzerland, with by far and away the greatest number coming from Germany (344/514). In all there are more than 500 ownership markings present in this geographically sorted album [2].

Distribution of book markings in "Germany" volume from the Offenbach Archival Depot

Each page of the album usually contained many reproductions of book markings crammed together with a reference number but no textual caption. Wanting to create a database of individual library marks, I began by isolating each bookstamp or mark from the album, beginning with those from Germany. I wanted to see geographically where these likely-destroyed libraries and private collections were located and to be able to sort out different types of institutions which had been targeted by the Nazis. The results of this mapping can be seen above and are searchable at http://viewshare.org/views/mfraas/offenbach-bookplates/ [does not work in IE].

In all I mapped 289 library markings to 127 locations with 55 markings remaining unknown to me (images of each individual library mark including the 55 unknown are also available on Flickr). The very top of the list is not surprising, Berlin and Frankfurt virtually tied (32 and 31) for the cities with the most library markings recorded in the Offenbach album, but I was a little surprised that the relatively small city of Hildesheim had as many markings recorded as Hamburg.


It should be kept in mind as well that these figures only represent those library markings in the "Germany" Offenbach album, countless private and otherwise unidentified-by-place markings exist in the other albums. I faced more difficulty in coming up with vocabulary with which to categorize the types of libraries present in this album. The overwhelming majority of book markings of course came from Jewish institutional or private libraries but in my cataloging of the book markings I have largely reserved the "Jewish" library label for institutional libraries such as those of synagogues and communal organizations and not private libraries of those who have names that might suggest Jewish ancestry. As a result, a significant number of library markings are coded as "other." Nonetheless as the map shows below, there is still value in looking at the library markings by type:


Cluster of Jewish libraries near Koblenz

NARA M1942 (reel 12, frame 541)
These caveats pale in comparison though to one of the central problems with making conclusions about wartime destruction of libraries based on the Offenbach albums. The Offenbach team photographed all the provenance marks on a book they could find, which do not necessarily represent the library from which they were looted. This can be readily seen in the "State Library" category on the map. The stamp of the Bibliothek des Bayerischen Landtags in Munich (right) is included in the "Germany" album but this obviously does not mean that the library was looted by the Third Reich, rather that the book had once been in the collections of that library at some unspecified prior point. Thus without further investigation it is difficult to know from this evidence exactly which library owned a given book on the day it was seized by the Third Reich.

First Page of "Germany" in album II (marks 1-7)

(this image: S.J. Pomrenze Papers, Center for Jewish History)
Nonetheless, I think mapping out these places of origin is exceedingly important when done with a more nuanced set of questions in mind. Taking the markings as evidence more broadly of the location of Jewish and other libraries in the decades prior to World War II  provides both a kind of historical recovery and might eventually offer data that could be used by scholars to make new arguments about the diffusion of reading and book culture in central Europe as well as its subsequent destruction.

Obviously mapping just shy of 350 library markings is not going to accomplish this task and I'm excited to move forward to try and catalog all of the markings in the Offenbach albums. This can only be accomplished by a large number of participants with the knowledge and language skills to identify often hard-to-read reproductions [3]. Fortunately, the Center for Jewish History in New York has digitized copies of the albums owned by Col. Seymour Pomrenze, one of the American officers assigned to Offenbach. These albums are virtually identical to those in the National Archives and the CJH digitized images are of better quality than the NARA microfilm. Though I haven't cataloged or geo-located them yet I have used the CJH images to put online the remaining 174 library markings from the "Western Europe" album on Flickr. Melanie Meyers and others at the CJH are working on identifying a broad swath of Eastern European and other marks from the albums and I hope in time a more complete picture, usable for research and discovery, emerges.



------------

[1]

This literature is large, a good introduction is the collection of essays The Holocaust and the Book: Destruction and Preservation (University of Massachusetts, 2001). Here at Penn, historian Kathy Peiss has been working for several years on the responses of the library profession to wartime looting and post-war book distribution/repatriation policies. See her "Cultural Policy in a Time of War: The American Response to Endangered Books in World War II," Library Trends 55.3 (2007), 370-386. For a specific example of work on the bookplates in the Offenbach collection see  Frederik J. Hoogewoud, "Dutch Jewish Ex Libris Found among Looted Books in the Offenbach Archival Depot (1946)” in Chaya Brasz & Yosef Kaplan, Dutch Jews as Perceived by Themselves and by Others. (Leiden, 2001), pp. 247-261 (a version is available online through the Clinton Presidential Library).

[2]

The "Western European" album (album II) can be found at the National Archives as NARA 260-LM-II-F and on microfilm as M1942 reel 12, frames 506-548. Another copy of this album is in the Colonel Seymour J. Pomrenze papers (P-933) at the Center for Jewish History  An additional copy of the bookplates can also be found at the University of Chicago (Codex Ms 1393). The NARA microfilm has also been digitized through Fold3 and is available online to members of that service at http://www.fold3.com/browsemore/hRyVVKV8Z_1/ .For the 344 "Germany" library markings mapped here I have used microfilm images from M1942 via Fold3, for the remaining 174 markings from album II on Flickr I have used digitized images from the Pomrenze papers at CJH.

[3]

Library markings from WWII-era books are already available online in a few forms outside of the Offenbach records. See for example the Brisman collection digitized at Washington University in St. Louis. The Koordinierungsstelle Magdeburg in Germany maintains a database at  Lostart.de which includes some descriptions and pictures of library markings in looted books.



53 comments:

  1. Wow library is one of the best place of gaining their knowledge. And your idea is really wonderful.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Environmental assignment writing services has become very popular among students seeking Environmental Health Writing Services and environmental health essay writing services.

    ReplyDelete
  3. common it problems Each profession has some challenges. However, the problem with most IT help desks is that they let many issues pile up to the extent that sorting them out becomes difficult. In this piece, you will get to learn about some common help desk problems and solutions.

    ReplyDelete
  4. If any student needs professional and affordable Assignment Help Australia services with best prices then once time check GoAssignmentHelp.com.au services. We offer assignment help, essay writing, dissertation, and homework services across the globe to the students who are pursuing their education at top universities. We have served so many clients all across the world, and they believe in our work and quality. GoAssignmentHelp.com.au is work 24/7 for your convenience, so you don’t need to wait for any central time you can contact us any time for any Assignment Help Melbourne. You can ask questions about your assignment to customer support executive or even directly get into touch with the professionals about any topic like Assignment Help Brisbane we resolve your problem. Get further detail by just dropping a mail to US.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It is really helpful for readers who are looking for PHP assignment help. I also work in the same area and provide assignment help to students for various subjects. Most of my students are from parts of the UK, USA, India, and Singapore. Visit our website to know our areas of expertise and let us know if we can be of help. Also Read:
    how many pages is 1000 words.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hire model escort girls from our Aerocity Escorts agency in 5-star hotels. We provide incall and outcall escorts service in Aerocity to make you happy.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Dear admin, I am Abbie from USA. I really enjoyed this website blogs with informative information. This is really so Great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free to many readers. It gives in depth information about this topic. Thanks for this valuable information and keep sharing more others blogs and topics. english assignment help - android assignment help - fashion assignment help - assignment help

    ReplyDelete
  8. This is a very skillful and technical topic and you make it seem so common and easy to understand. Your insight into the topic is amazing, and I want to encourage you to keep posting good content like this. betking booking

    ReplyDelete
  9. Are you seeking essay helps in the UK? We know students generally face the problem in essay writing during their academic career. Writing an essay is very challenging for students.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Assignment Help assistance that is taken online is easy smooth and efficient. It does the job for all the students and all the students love to take the online assignment assistance for finishing their assignments. due to the easy availability and purchase of online assignment help can be used by any student of the world and they can take its benefit as per their convenience

    ReplyDelete
  11. I believe this will help your website become more organized because you have decided to set a part on this site for the inquiries regarding tax and as well as the helpful discussions. To be honest, this is one of the few sites that are doing this kind of strategy. Also, I think that this will not only benefit your clients help with assignment or the potential ones but you most especially because you will be able to see the questions easier.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Everyone should have to read the books that very great benefits for the knowledge as one qoute I remember readers are leaders. When I got free time from redlink then I used to book or article.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Free vashikaran specialist Vashikaran “Sanskrit language, which is used widely in the field of astrology, is a word. It’s the Sanskrit language Free Vashikaran Specialist Vashikaran will not be an obscure term for you if you have been searching for a vashikaran expert and looking for one here too. Vashikaran Specialist in Bangalore However, vashikaran was also utilized at the time of kings and queens to control the brains of individuals related to them. Love Marriage Specialist in Mumbai
    . Astrologer Rohit

    ReplyDelete
  14. Consult with Astrologer Ganesh Shastri Ji who is One of Powerful Love Vashikaran Specialist Astrologer available to solve your all problems with ease & perfection. ||Love Vashikaran Specialist
    ||Vashikaran Specialist Astrologer
    ||vashikaran specialist

    ReplyDelete
  15. Do you want to get Love Problem Solution on call? Are you finding a love problem solution online? There is no need to go anywhere to get a online love problem solution astrologer. ||Online love problem solution astrologer||Love Marriage Problem Solution Baba Ji

    ReplyDelete
  16. I clearly stumbled upon your weblog and favored to mention that I’ve truely loved reading your blog posts. anyhow I’ll be subscribing in your feed and that i wish you submit once more quickly. help with assignment Please keeps it top posting! thanks you a lot, I recognize your work.

    ReplyDelete
  17. We have read your all the information some points are good .
    Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article.

    english stories gk quiz app english stories collection

    ReplyDelete
  18. ​Do you sustain too hard for taking the better response of your question? I am looking around to have new logic in you post. So, it would be better to get in touch with Assignment Help Service at any cost.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thanks for such wonderful blog that looks pretty different, I would suggest you please make a proper plan for your blog and start professional blogging as a career, One day you would be paper writing service smart enough to earn some money, wishing you a best of luck my friend, Thanks a lot for your nice support and love.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Thank you�� Foreign visitors who wish to visit the Turkey need to apply visa to Turkey online. apply for Turkey evisa, travelers need to fill out an application form, select your country and click on the blue button that reads- Apply.

    ReplyDelete
  21. The very next time I read a blog, I hope that it won’t fail me as much as this particular one. I mean, Yes, it was my choice to read through, however I genuinely believed you would have something helpful to say. essay assistance uk All I hear is a bunch of complaining about something that you could fix if you weren’t too busy searching for attention.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Great write up. I have never seen such a masterpiece formulated with precision, accuracy and much-needed information. Thanks for sharing. But you want to access ample datasets for your assignments, take free assistance from SourceEssay Essay Typer.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Our company was founded by a group of white and blue collar average individuals who were tired of getting the runaround on Product and Service (Labor) warranties that either didn’t come with the purchase, was misplaced or lost over time , at risk of expiring which needs an extension. This daily runaround came from everyday well-known manufacturers and retailers in our local neighborhoods. The manufacturers and retailers we are referring to always found something in the “fine print” to discredit and disqualify the warranty policy of the product or service. This leaves us, the consumer, with no alternative other than to buy a new product or pay for the service again.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thank you The international travelers who travel to Kenya need kenya online visa. That they can apply online and can get the 24*7 customer assistant.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Hi, I really enjoyed reading your post, and hope to read more. Thank you so much for sharing this. best insurance for car

    ReplyDelete
  26. Dispensary care is Weed what many people lack in the interior areas of the world. Weed, can help you recover shortly. marijuana. people face a lot of health issues everyday without solution. Weed However, marijuana has always been a perfect remedy for ill health. Nevertheless, cocaine may also help.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Buy Current Documents deal in legal documents of all kinds such as ID’s card, Passports, Driving’s License, birth certificates etc. We can also help you in case you need a whole new identity for yourself by getting you registered in the government records. We provide all these services at very minimal costs, and with our high tech machinery, it will be impossible for anyone to prove that your documents are illegal. We also provide a doorstep deliver of the documents, so that you don’t have to waste your time and effort in obtaining your documents from us. For any kind of document you need, contact us.

    Buy Current Documents pride ourselves as the best online store for documents and we have grown over time into the most reliable and professional producers documents makers online comprised of the best team of dedicated designers and affiliated with other top producers .We always advice Our customers to ask us any question and to express to us their worries since we do the best we can to satisfy them so that they can feel free to buy real documents.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Our website Gearmart.pk is an online store that sells products related to Camping and Hiking in Pakistan. We are not only limited to camping and hiking but sell a wide variety of products. Check the store to buy products at reasonable prices.

    ReplyDelete
  29. I love to read this, thank you... apply for Indian tourist visa online is easy. You can apply online completely securely through eVisa Indian website.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Is this a paid theme or did you modify it yourself?
    Either way stay up the excellent high quality writing, it is uncommon to see a great blog like this one these days..
    섯다

    ReplyDelete
  31. I Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look forward
    to all your posts! Carry on the superb work!
    스포츠토토

    ReplyDelete
  32. we are provide online assignmnet help Canada,"We Have The Best Team! i am check your question and provde best assignmnet help. Need article Specialist who can draft quality tasks without making it extreme to pay? Recruit www.assignmenthelppro.com/ca/. We are the main web-based paper help administration in the canada who will compose a quality exposition for you at sensible rates.

    ReplyDelete
  33. It is good to hear that your store is now expanding to new locations. I have been a patron of Fantastic Eyes because of all the wonderful work that you guys do. I hope that this expansion move of yours will turn out to be successful. I will definitely essay helper uk go and see this new store of yours

    ReplyDelete
  34. Postknight mod apk is a game where you collect all the missing letters in the kingdom. You will be doing this by traveling worldwide and fighting bad guys. The game is similar to an RPG, and it has a lot of elements from other games like Pokemon, Osu!, and even some from Final Fantasy (the name "Postknight" is most likely based on the Chocobo from Final Fantasy). The graphics are beautiful, and the gameplay is enjoyable.
    https://apkmodule.com/postknight-mod-apk/

    ReplyDelete
  35. Fast-paced, thrilling 3D Tank Hero Mod Apk action for your Android phone. Shoot your enemies from the front, lay down shields or napkin shields, or call in the tanks to do the fighting. Battle against cunning, relentless enemies and become the ultimate Tank Hero! " Tank Hero is an exciting game that evolves on its own" - Slide To Play. Available now for free download!
    Enjoy the intense tank hero apk action with the unique gameplay of Tank Hero Android App. Tank Heroes is elite soldiers that fight off enemy attacks with powerful weapons or shields. The more enemies you kill the more points you earn. Plus you also get rewarded for making fewer enemies. You can't die! This game provides unlimited hours of excitement as you blast your way through waves of enemy soldiers, zombies, robots, and more.
    https://apkmodule.com/tank-hero-mod-apk/

    ReplyDelete
  36. Vashikaran Specialist IN Punjab AMRITSAR –

    ReplyDelete
  37. I am enjoying every bit of it. It is a good site, as well as the stock is well-chosen. Thank you.. Indian visa photo requirements for US citizens, You can check the Indian e visa website. And read here all photo requirements for US citizens

    ReplyDelete
  38. Manish Sharma Ji is the love vashikaran specialist astrologer providing solution for Love, Family, Business, Marriage Problems. Get perfect solutions for each problem. Stop disillusionment, catch Happiness. These days, the most famous and acclaimed Family problem solution astrologer and distinctive significant Love problem solution specialist.

    ReplyDelete
  39. LOVE Problem specialist baba ji – 8437491131

    ReplyDelete
  40. It generally bears the marks of the library, which may take the form of stamps, embossed seals, written call numbers, or even a glued-in pocket for a check-out card.

    ReplyDelete
  41. I am working as a SEO Analyst.My blog gives information about latest technologies and IT Courses.
    write for us technology guest post

    ReplyDelete
  42. Marks and the digital Library continue to expand WorthPoint’s commitment to help collectors turn information into knowledge.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Exceptional article, also if you need any help related to the spacebar clicker games. An online tool to count the total number of clicks you have performed in a predefined time duration using the space bar click test.Please visit and share your thoughts.

    ReplyDelete
  44. This is an excellent post I seen thanks to share it. It is really what I wanted to see hope in future you will continue for sharing such a excellent post. bitmain antminer s19

    ReplyDelete
  45. Great post. I was constantlys and new initiatives in the same niche. Blog gave us useful information to work. You have done an amazing job! 먹튀검증

    ReplyDelete
  46. I am still learning of your stuff, and i am attempting to achieve my objectives. I completely adore reading through all that is written in your website. Maintain the actual ideas arriving for long term ! Thanks ! Great info! I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have. I discovered your this post while taking a gander at for some related information on blog search...It's a not all that horrendous post..keep posting and invigorate the information. I’m sure it is the most vital information for me personally. And i am glad reading your article. But should remark on few general things, Your website style is ideal, the articles really is excellent . 승인전화없는 카지노

    ReplyDelete
  47. nderstand several threads within this web page in addition to I'm sure that a world-wide-web blog site is usually authentic useful possesses bought bags connected with excellent facts. 안전토토사이트

    ReplyDelete
  48. Thanks for this article and the opportunity to learn more about italian culture

    ReplyDelete